Year: 2026 | Month: May | Volume: 13 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 536-559
DOI: https://doi.org/10.52403/ijrr.20260550
Biochar for Climate-Resilient Soil and Water Conservation: A Critical Review
Bontor L. Tobing1, Fitryane Lihawa2, Abdul Samad Hiola3, Asda Rauf4, Wahyuni K. Baderan5
1,3Doctoral Program in Environmental Science, Universitas Negeri Gorontalo, Gorontalo, Indonesia.
2,4,5Postgraduate Program, Universitas Negeri Gorontalo, Gorontalo, Indonesia.
Corresponding Author: Fitryane Lihawa
ABSTRACT
Biochar is increasingly positioned at the interface of renewable carbon management, sustainable agriculture, and land-degradation control. This critical review synthesizes evidence from global meta-analyses and recent mechanistic and field studies to evaluate how biochar contributes to runoff reduction, soil erosion control, and climate-resilient soil function. Yet its value for runoff and water-erosion mitigation remains highly context dependent because biochar properties interact with soil texture, rainfall regime, slope, vegetation cover, and time since application. The updated evidence indicates that biochar can reduce runoff and soil loss, but rarely as a stand-alone or universally scalable amendment. Instead, its most defensible function is as a soil sponge-stability-vegetation intervention that redistributes rainfall, strengthens aggregate and rill-flow resistance, and improves the biological cover needed for durable erosion control. Recent field and mechanistic studies refine the earlier meta-analytic conclusions by showing dose optima near low-to-moderate topsoil concentrations, larger responses in coarse and medium-textured soils, event-scale dependence under high-erosivity rainfall, and strong synergies with vegetation, mulch, and filter-strip systems. The same evidence also identifies risks that must be managed, including phosphorus percolation, fine-particle export, increased surface runoff in karst settings, high-rate detachment responses, salinity, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and aging under compaction. We therefore propose a precision framework that matches feedstock, pyrolysis conditions, particle size, rate, placement depth, co-amendments, and monitoring endpoints to dominant erosion pathways. Future progress requires multi-year field trials, standardized reporting, pathway-specific hydrological accounting, and integration with circular biomass and climate-resilient land-management strategies.
Keywords: biochar; soil erosion; runoff; sponge function; soil structure; vegetation cover; hydrological connectivity
[PDF Full Text]